🏛️ Board of Trustees
Albion Police Resignation Highlights Department Strain Amid Contract Disputes
A decorated Albion Police officer resigned this week, citing a lack of support from village leadership and superior benefits at a competing agency. The departure comes amid ongoing contract negotiations that the officer described as "upsetting."
▶
Key Actions & Decisions
●
Accepted resignation of Police Officer Alexandra Reigl (read resignation letter into record).
●
Discussed banking services with KeyBank representative regarding potential treasury management changes.
●
Reviewed employee attendance and usage records.
ALBION — The Village Board of Trustees met on Dec. 26 to address routine end-of-year business, but the meeting was overshadowed by the resignation of a young police officer who cited a toxic relationship between the Village Board and the police department as her reason for leaving.
The board accepted the resignation of Police Officer Alexandra Reigl, effective immediately. In a resignation letter read into the record during the meeting, Reigle offered a candid assessment of the department’s morale and her critique of village leadership.
Reigle, who spent three years with the Albion Police Department, announced she is joining a neighboring agency. While she thanked Police Chief David Mogile and Lt. William Annable for their mentorship, her praise for village administration was noticeably absent.
"The decision to leave the Albion Police Department was not an easy one for me," Reigle wrote. "I have made many friendships here and have had an amazing opportunity to grow... The Albion Police Department has been a second family for me."
However, Reigle noted that the department has struggled with internal accountability and its relationship with neighboring law enforcement agencies.
"It is sad to see those relationships go rocky or see people inside the department not wanting to work with other people," Reigle stated.
The resignation letter leveled significant criticism at Mayor John Javier and the Deputy Mayor regarding their support of law enforcement. Reigle compared the leadership style of her new employer—a town supervisor she interviewed with—to that of the Village Board.
"In my three years at Albion, I have not seen that support from the Village Mayor or Deputy Mayor," Reigle wrote. "It was extremely upsetting to see our Union and the Village spend so much money on lawyers for everyone to settle on something so simple and minuscule."
Reigle’s departure highlights the ongoing friction between the village and its police union. Contract negotiations have been contentious this year, leading to legal fees that Reigle described as wasteful. She also criticized the contracts offered by the village, stating they fell short of what was needed to retain talent.
Beyond the internal strife, Reigle pointed to structural disadvantages in Albion’s compensation package compared to other agencies. She noted that the new department offers a path to promotion—specifically an Investigator position—which is currently unavailable in Albion. She also cited "lifetime medical after retirement" and "compensatory time" options that allow for overtime to be taken as time off rather than pay, a flexibility she felt was lacking in Albion.
"It was hard for me to see this as an option at Albion when our contract negotiations went the way they did this year," she wrote.
The loss of an officer with three years of experience is a setback for the department. Reigle expressed hope that future village leadership would change the dynamic.
"I hope that whoever steps foot into the Village next election gives this department the respect and support the Officer’s deserve," she concluded.
In other business, the board reviewed correspondence from Ray Perechinsky, a Senior Client Manager at KeyBank. The correspondence, dated Nov. 7, 2024, detailed potential costs for a daily check issue service.
According to the minutes, Perechinsky outlined a "flat $751 a month" fee based on accounts and volumes, with an additional "$110 month" fee if the village chose to send in a daily check issue file. The board discussed the treasury management proposal, though no action was taken to change banking providers during the meeting.
The board also authorized the payment of bills and reviewed employee attendance records.
The Dec. 26 meeting was one of the final sessions for the current board before the new organizational meeting in January. Reigle’s resignation leaves a vacancy in the department that will need to be addressed by Chief Mogile in the coming year.
Coverage of the Board of Trustees meeting on 2024-12-26,
Village of Albion, NY.
View original document ↗
This article was drafted by AI (claude-sonnet-4-20250514) from the official meeting transcript and reviewed by a human editor.
Quotes link to source video timestamps for verification.
Read our editorial policy.
🔍
Ask Albion
Have a question about this story? Search across meeting transcripts, village history, and municipal code.
Related Board of Trustees Meetings
2024-12-19
Albion Trustees Fill Key Water Department Post, Approve New Mechanic and Equipment
▶
Key Actions & Decisions
●
Appointed Levi Boyer as Chief Water Treatment Plant (WTP) Operator with a starting salary of $78,314.50 (Vote: 4-0).
●
Authorized DPW Superintendent Jay Pahura to purchase an air-tow trailer and truck (Vote: 3-0).
●
Approved hiring Shawn Diebel as an Auto Mechanic for the DPW (Vote: 3-0).
●
Granted Planning Board Chair Karen Conn permission to sign a letter of support for a Restore NY grant application.
●
Authorized Boyer, as Acting Chief, to hire a vacant WTP operator trainee position.
2025-01-08
Water Grant Progress, Downtown Revitalization Discussed at Albion Board Meeting
▶
Key Actions & Decisions
●
Approved $298,024.50 payment to Statewide Aquastore Inc. for the Water NY Grant (WIIA 2) project.
●
Approved $12,772.51 in contingency funds for Department of Public Works (DPW) camera systems.
●
Authorized engagement letter with MMB+Co for the May 31, 2025 fiscal year audit.
●
Tabled decisions on Positive Pay options and Internet/Phone services until Jan 22.
●
Accepted donations totaling $1,250 ($1,000 for July Celebration, $250 to GoArt).
●
Scheduled public meeting for Jan 30, 2025, at Snell’s Realty to discuss downtown improvements.
2024-12-11
Albion Trustees End Fire Contracts with Town, Target Main Street Redevelopment
▶
Key Actions & Decisions
●
Fire contracts terminated: The board unanimously ended the 2022-2026 contract with the Town of Albion and the 2023-2027 contract with the Town of Gaines, effective Dec. 31, 2024.
●
Restore NY grant application: Unanimously approved Resolution 2024-29 to apply for state funding to rehabilitate 132 N. Main Street, a vacant mixed-use building, for commercial space and affordable housing.
●
Water infrastructure appropriations: Approved budget adjustments increasing expenses and revenues by $192,923.30 for the WIIA 2 Project and $15,664.71 for the WIIA 1 Project.
●
Personnel changes: Accepted resignation of Police Officer Alexandra Reigle and Deputy Treasurer Derek Reiner; authorized the hiring process to fill the police vacancy.
●
Monthly bills paid: Approved $94,108.88 in total payments across general, water, sewer, and capital funds.
●
Property surplus: Approved the sale of three surplus firearms to Albion Gun Shop for $100 each.
●
GOART donation: Authorized up to $500 from recreation reserve funds for a donation to GOART (Greater Orleans Arts Together).
●
Cemetery deeds: Approved deeds for Anne E. Neilans and Clark M. & Anne M. Brooks.
2025-01-22
Albion Animal Control Passes State Inspection Amid Busy Year for Local Wildlife
▶
Key Actions & Decisions
●
Animal Control Reviewed: The board acknowledged the 2024 annual report from Animal Control Officer Harry Papponetti.
●
State Inspection Passed: A November 2024 inspection by the NYS Department of Agriculture and Markets found the facility "satisfactory" regarding dog capture, holding, and euthanasia practices.
●
Wildlife Activity Highlighted: Data showed increased interactions with local wildlife, including reports of coyotes, foxes, and bats.
2025-02-05
Water Infrastructure Repairs, New Police Officer Highlight Albion Board Meeting
▶
Key Actions & Decisions
●
Approved use of Water Reserve Funds to repair the High Service Pump at the Water Treatment Plant.
●
Authorized the Chief Water Treatment Operator and DPW Superintendent to locate and repair a leak at Booster Station 1.
●
Hired Cory J. Martindale as a new Police Officer/Patrolman at Step 3 pay.
●
Requested all Department Heads submit 1, 3, and 5-year project projections for budget hearings.
●
Signed an Encroachment Agreement with Jaime Riveria for a garage and fence at 33 Caroline Street.
●
Approved an eviction notice for a tenant at the Cemetery Apartment.
●
Tabled discussions on crossing guard staffing and Low Service Pump repairs to February 12.
Community Discussion
0 commentsBe the first to comment on this story.